Innovation is a key component of success in today’s ever-evolving business landscape. Conducting performance reviews and evaluating employees specifically on their ability to innovate can help drive growth and inspire a culture of creativity and improvement.

To determine an employee’s rating for innovation, asking targeted questions during the performance review can help gain valuable insight. For example, asking how the employee has contributed to the development or improvement of a product, service, or process can illuminate their creative problem-solving skills. Another question could be how they encouraged or supported a culture of innovation within their team or department. By combining effective questioning techniques with a clear rating scale and specific examples, supervisors can enhance the accuracy and effectiveness of innovation-focused performance reviews.

Related: Best Performance Review Examples for 48 Key Skills

2000+ Performance Review Phrases: The Complete List (Performance Feedback Examples)

Performance Review Questions: Innovation

These questions help to establish a clear understanding of the employee’s performance in terms of innovation and provide valuable insight for assigning an accurate rating:

1. Has the employee come up with any new ideas or suggestions that have been implemented successfully?
2. Has the employee demonstrated a willingness to take risks and try new approaches to problem-solving?
3. Does the employee take the initiative to research and implement new strategies or technologies to improve workflow or performance?
4. Has the employee contributed to the development of new products, services, or processes?
5. Has the employee demonstrated an ability to think outside the box and come up with innovative solutions to challenges?
6. Has the employee shown a capacity to learn and adapt to new technologies and methodologies?
7. Has the employee demonstrated a passion for innovation and a desire to drive change within the organization?
8. Has the employee shown a capacity to collaborate with others to generate new ideas and approaches?
9. Has the employee shown a capacity to identify and seize opportunities for innovation within the organization?
10. Has the employee shown a capacity to communicate their ideas effectively and persuasively to others?

Performance Review Phrases and Paragraphs Examples: Innovation

5 – Outstanding

A rating of 5, or Outstanding, represents an employee who consistently demonstrates exceptional innovation. They may frequently generate groundbreaking ideas and solutions, often going above and beyond their job role. This employee is an inspiration to their peers and can solve complex issues with ease.

Phrases Examples:

• Consistently introduces innovative ideas that have a significant positive impact on the company’s performance.
• Is highly proactive in researching and implementing new strategies to improve workflow and efficiency.
• Is never hesitant to share her unique insights and ideas that drive substantial improvements in team performance.
• Continuously creates groundbreaking solutions and ideas.
• Adept at challenging assumptions and thinking outside the box.
• Frequently inspires others to adopt innovative approaches.

Paragraph Examples:

“Jane is a highly innovative employee, constantly challenging conventional thinking and inspiring her team to explore new ideas. She has consistently delivered groundbreaking results and has played a crucial role in the recent product launches that have exceeded expectations.”

“Samantha has an outstanding ability to think outside the box and consistently offers innovative ideas that contribute to the overall success of the company. Her proactive approach towards researching and developing new strategies to improve our workflow and efficiency has been instrumental in the growth of our department. Not only does she generate creative solutions to complex problems, but she also shares her valuable insights with the team, leading to substantial improvements in performance.”

4 – Exceeds Expectations

The rating “Exceeds Expectations”, indicates that the employee displays a high level of innovation. They generate creative ideas and solutions, occasionally exceeding the requirements of their job role. Employees who exceed expectations in their innovative thinking show an ability to think outside-of-the-box and bring fresh ideas to the table. Here are some phrases and paragraph examples that demonstrate an employee’s outstanding performance in innovation:

• Proactive problem solver: This employee consistently identifies potential issues before they become larger problems and suggests innovative solutions to overcome them. Their foresight and creative approach to problem-solving have led to improvements in processes, systems, and overall efficiency.
• Creative thinker: This employee consistently generates innovative ideas and suggestions for new products, processes, or ways to improve existing systems. They are not afraid to take risks, and their courage to implement new ideas has led to impressive results and industry recognition.
• Embraces change: This employee demonstrates a willingness to embrace change and proactively seeks opportunities to adapt their role or responsibilities to better serve the company. They continuously push boundaries and search for new techniques and tools to make their work more efficient and effective.
• Collaborative innovator: This employee consistently collaborates with colleagues to develop groundbreaking ideas and solutions. Their ability to work and communicate well with a diverse group of professionals has fostered a culture of innovation throughout the company.

Phrases Examples:

• Consistently demonstrates a creative and innovative approach to problem-solving.
• Has a proven track record of developing and implementing new ideas that have positively impacted the company.
• Displays a high level of ingenuity in identifying and addressing challenges in the workplace.
• Regularly contributes to the development of new products and services that have exceeded expectations.
• Demonstrates a willingness to take calculated risks and explore new opportunities for growth.
• Shows a strong ability to think outside the box and come up with original solutions to complex problems.
• Consistently brings fresh perspectives and ideas to team meetings and discussions.
• Has a reputation for being an innovative thinker and a valuable asset to the organization.
• Displays a natural curiosity and a passion for exploring new technologies and trends in the industry.
• Has a proven ability to turn innovative ideas into successful projects that deliver tangible results.

Paragraph Example:

“Jennifer has shown exceptional creativity and adaptability in her role. Her ability to identify potential areas of growth for our product line has truly set her apart from her peers. Her willingness to take risks, experiment, and challenge the status quo has not only led to the successful launch of several new products but has also inspired her teammates to think more creatively. Jennifer truly embodies what it means to exceed expectations in regard to innovation.”

3 – Meets Expectations

An employee with a rating of 3, or Meets Expectations, demonstrates sufficient innovation skills. They are capable of coming up with creative solutions to problems and contribute to the success of the organization. Their performance aligns with the expectations of their position, and they consistently meet the set standards.

Phrases Examples:

• Consistently generates creative ideas to improve existing processes or products
• Effectively embraces change and adapts to new environments or situations
• Demonstrates an open-minded approach to problem-solving
• Actively seeks out opportunities for personal and professional growth in the area of innovation
• Regularly contributes to team brainstorming sessions, fostering a culture of creativity and collaboration

Paragraph Examples:

“Jane consistently generates creative ideas for improving our department’s workflows. She is always willing to research new technologies and tools that could enhance our efficiency and streamline processes. This has led to the successful implementation of several innovative solutions that have positively impacted our team’s overall performance.”

“In the face of evolving industry trends, John has proven to be adaptable and open-minded when addressing new challenges. He has effectively embraced change and demonstrated resiliency by seeking out opportunities to learn about emerging technologies and approaches relevant to his role. This dedication contributes to our team’s ability to stay competitive within our market.”

“Sarah’s open-minded approach to problem-solving has been instrumental in the success of several projects this year. She is always willing to consider alternative solutions and encourages her colleagues to think outside the box. Her collaborative attitude during brainstorming sessions has fostered a more innovative environment within the team.”

2 – Needs Improvement

A rating of 2, or Needs Improvement, signifies that the employee is not meeting the expected level of innovation. The employee may occasionally generate innovative ideas, but they need to invest more effort and focus to develop their skills further. A continuous lack of innovation may limit the employee’s ability to perform well in their job role and hinder their career growth. It is important for managers to provide necessary feedback and support to aid the improvement of these employees. Employees who struggle with innovation may need guidance and support to develop their creative thinking and problem-solving skills.

Phrases Examples:

• “Jane struggles to think outside the box and come up with new ideas or approaches to problems.”
• “John relies too heavily on traditional methods and has difficulty embracing new technologies or processes.”
• “Sarah tends to avoid taking risks and exploring novel ways of doing things, which can hinder innovation in the team.”
• “David could benefit from developing his critical thinking skills and being more open to change and new ideas.”

Paragraph Examples:

“Jane, I’ve noticed that when the team is brainstorming, you tend to stick with familiar ideas and don’t often contribute new thoughts. It’s important to be willing to take risks and explore different possibilities, even if they don’t always work out. I’d like to see you challenge yourself to come up with more innovative solutions to problems. Consider taking a course on creative thinking or collaborating with colleagues who have a knack for innovation to help you break out of your comfort zone.”

“John, I appreciate your dedication to completing tasks efficiently, but sometimes your reliance on established methods prevents you from discovering more effective ways of working. For example, when we introduced the new project management software, you continued using spreadsheets to track progress, which made it difficult for the team to stay aligned. Moving forward, I’d like you to be more open to embracing new tools and processes, even if it means stepping out of your comfort zone. This will support the team’s overall innovation efforts and contribute to our success.”

“Sarah, your risk-averse approach can sometimes limit the team’s creativity and ability to innovate. I understand that taking risks can be challenging, but it’s an important aspect of pushing the boundaries and finding better ways to work. I encourage you to embrace change and be more open to experimenting with new ideas, even if there’s a chance they might not succeed. This can help foster a more innovative environment within the team.”

“David, developing your critical thinking skills and being more receptive to new ideas is crucial for promoting innovation in our team. I’ve noticed that you often dismiss suggestions without giving them proper consideration, which can stifle creative thinking. In the future, I’d like you to work on being more open-minded and analyzing suggestions and ideas more thoroughly before making a decision. This will create a more collaborative and innovative atmosphere among your colleagues.”

1 – Unacceptable

“Unacceptable” rating represents an employee who lacks innovation in their performance. This employee rarely comes up with creative solutions and may be hindering project progress or the overall success of the organization. It is crucial for managers to address this lack of innovation through performance improvement plans or additional training.

• Stagnant thought process: The employee is unwilling to explore new ideas and consistently relies on outdated methods.
• Resistance to change: The employee often resists the implementation of new ideas or processes, hindering the team’s overall progress.
• Lack of curiosity: The employee does not actively seek out new knowledge, leading to a limited understanding of industry trends or advancements.
• Inability to think outside the box: The employee struggles to develop creative solutions to problems or generate unique ideas.

Phrases Examples:

• Does the employee actively seek out new ideas, best practices, or technologies?
• How often does the employee propose fresh and viable ideas for problem-solving or process improvement?
• Is the employee open to trying different approaches or adaptable to change?
• Does the employee consistently challenge their own ideas or assumptions to improve and evolve?

Paragraph Examples:

“John consistently demonstrates resistance to change and a reluctance to adopt new ideas or methods. His unwillingness to explore different approaches limits the team’s ability to successfully innovate and adapt. This has resulted in missed opportunities and potential roadblocks to our growth.”

“Susan does not exhibit curiosity or a desire to learn about industry trends and advancements. Her stagnant thought process often results in outdated solutions that hinder the team’s progress. To successfully contribute to our team’s innovative efforts, Susan must be more open to learning and implementing new ideas.”